September 24, 2008


Frequent fps contributor, René Walling and I rolled into Ottawa from Montreal fairly late on Friday night, both disappointed to have missed out on The New Wave Of Japanese Animation that had screened at 7pm that evening. Our options limited, we set ourselves toward the Empire Cinema across the street from our shared Novotel room, where we had quickly shed our luggage. We were just in time to catch a screening of one of the films in the running for best feature of the fest: a little independent CG number called, Terra.

Terra sets itself up as an alien invasion tale turned on its head. Happy little, sentient tadpole people float blissfully through their naive lives in a Miyazaki film/Flight GN inspired world of flying whale-things, gliders and airships until the fateful day when a "god" appears in the sky. The god turns out to be a giant, spinning spaceship carrying an invasion force of humans, desperate to take the planet as their new home. Amidst an explosive torrent of sci-fi action and Planet of the Apes riffing revelation, we follow fishy, doe-eyed Mala (voiced by Evan Rachel Wood) through a step-by-step Campbell-style "Hero Journey" to fulfill her destiny and save her people from extinction. To its credit, the film manages to throw enough plot and character curve balls to keep the structure from being too cookie-cutter familiar but rarely ascends beyond anything more than a simple story twist, illustrated with a collection of elements cobbled together from an animation fan's nerd-moist-dreams.

Read more after the jump:


Which leads me to question who the audience is for this film? It lacks the depth that adults require of character pieces like Ghibli's Only Yesterday or the internal consistency of the better sci-fi/fantasies like Ghost in the Shell or Macross (the filmmakers never manage to bridge the gap between the fantasy-science of the tadpole Terrans and the real-worldish science of the humans). We're constantly asked to suspend belief beyond reasonable realms (Mala is able to, within minutes, build an atmospheric containment chamber large enough to house a grown adult spaceman) while being led by the nose from plot point to plot point, all the while suffering a perpetual head-clubbing by the hammer of the films "message". There isn't much subtlety in Terra. Is that because it's made to appeal to children? I can't say for certain that my eight-year-old nephew would care for it either (This review would have been so much easier to write if he'd been with me!) The pseudo-science concepts that much of the plot hinges upon may be too technical for youngsters to grasp, keeping them at arms length from the main thrust of the narrative. Add to that a potentially inappropriate level of violence and death and Terra becomes a film that my sister might not appreciate having screened for her little boy.

For what it's worth, the full-length movie from artist/director Aristomenis Tsirbas is a minor triumph in that the quality of the Maya (character animation), LightWave 3D (modeling, texturing, lighting, rendering) and Modo (additional modeling, bridging) animation is such that it can compete at the box-office with larger studio films. Both design work and animation quality are uneven (humans have a distinct and well designed Pixar style to their faces and a completely flat and formless shape to their body and dress) but not so offensive that children or less discriminating adults will take notice. The combination of the inconsistent writing and animation was certainly distracting enough to pull me out of the feature at times but I felt that I might have been in the minority in the theatre. After all, it won the Grand Prize for Best Animated Feature at the fest.

Labels: , , , , ,

Comments:
You were not a minority in the audience. Most people i talked to who saw it and myself included thought it was worthy of MST3k in parts. All of us were surprised it won best film over "Sita Sings the Blues".

Judging from the murmurs in the audience at the awards after the announcements I think many people were surprised it won over Sita. Terra had it's moments but Sita was by far and away a much more entertaining and better crafted film.
Not even close to being alone - though I wonder what the audience at the Empire screening was; I was at the Bytowne Sunday screening, and many of the regular festival-goers there just kinda blinked at each other in silent questioning of "was this as bad as I thought? am I alone in thinking this?" which was rapidly answered. A collective silent sigh issued fom the exiting masses.

I will agree, however, that for an independent non-big-studio release, it's worthy of attention; the visual quality was more than enough to pull me in. If only they hadn't skimped on the story, instead of shopping at Campbell's Clearance House of Clichés. Good call on the Flight feel, though that's not necessarily a bad influence. In fact, they'd have done better going to one of the storytellers from Flight and try to adapt/expand on one of those stories instead - there are numerous that could lend themseles to such a thing, and many Flight contributors are animators.

Sita was better, though I figured Bashir would win, as it was more to me slightly more coherent and paced than Sita; it's only past the second cut at the end that I went "out" of the movie. (I didn't see Plympton's entry.)

-Niall
I personally preferred Terra quite a bit over Sita. My friends were mostly in favor of Terra as well but not unanimously. It deserved the big prize but I wouldn't have been surprised if Sita won either. Both films have considerable merits albeit in different respects.


> Search
> Site Archives
> Blog Archives
> Upcoming Releases
> RSS Feeds