Review
Star Wars: Clone Wars Volume One
Emru Townsend · April 11, 2005 | It's an unfortunate truth that, since the movies' existence, Star Wars hasn't mixed well with television or animation. It's also an unfortunate truth that every new Star Wars endeavour after the original trilogy has had mixed reviews at best. And yet when I read about Clone Wars when it was still in pre-production, I instantly knew I would enjoy it. The reason why can be summed up in one name: Genndy Tartakovsky.

I loved Tartakovsky's Dexter's Laboratory, and its many genre parodies (blaxploitation hero Action Hank, in particular) proved that Tartakovsky knew how to distill a concept to its thematic, visual and kinetic essence. His sophomore series Samurai Jack reaffirmed this skill—and coincidentally its bizarre creatures, ascetic warrior, and alien yet familiar settings placed him that much closer to the Star Wars universe.

Bridging Attack of the Clones and the forthcoming Revenge of the Sith, Clone Wars is a Cartoon Network "micro-series," where the "micro" refers to the length of each episode, a little over three minutes. The abbreviated running time works in the series' favour; by breaking the story down into tiny, compact episodes, we regain something that's been lost from Star Wars for some time: the feel of a mid-twentieth century movie serial. It's welcome, and it also serves a counterbalance—because in another significant way Clone Wars loses something integral to Star Wars: an awful lot of it is pantomime. Some of this is simply due to the subject matter: Clone Wars focuses on the grand campaigns of the war itself, the secret war of the Sith versus the Jedi, and the internal war that Anakin experiences as he wrestles with his (and the Force's) dark side and clashes with Obi-Wan Kenobi. That leaves a lot of room for battle scenes, and not much room for Star Wars' characteristic talkiness.

Still, it gives Tartakovsky and his team the chance to tell stories using nothing but animation, which is something rarely afforded to people who work in television animation. Tartakovsky's team have learned their lessons from Samurai Jack well: the ARC troopers (elite clone troopers) exude professional coolness with their deadly, efficient silence, and the entirely wordless episode featuring Mace Windu and the fanciest Jedi moves you've ever seen is beautifully choreographed.

Star Wars: Clone Wars Volume One
Twentieth Century Fox Home Entertainment, 2005
Originally broadcast in 2003
Directed by Genndy Tartakovsky
69 minutes

Shop for Clone Wars DVDs and more:
Amazon.ca
Amazon.com
But as assured as Clone Wars is as a series, it stumbles as a DVD. Presenting all twenty chapters as one movie (a wipe signals the transition from one chapter to another) reveals why the Star Wars movies are so talky: eventually, you need a break from all the action. Even Samurai Jack, which Tartakovsky conceived as a straight action show, had lengthy moments of serenity; there are a few such scenes in Clone Wars, but they aren't nearly enough.

The DVD extras also came up short. Tartakovsky has two director commentaries (one cheesily and pointlessly referred to as the "Hyperspace commentary"), but together they don't impart enough for the curious fan. Long on generalities and fannish admiration, they tantalize with tidbits about the production but offer little follow-up. I was particularly interested in where they decided to stick with traditional techniques instead of digital. It's revealed that in one lengthy, high-speed dogfight, they found it too complex to create the backgrounds digitally and instead did it the old-fashioned way, with one long hand-drawn background-long enough to extend far out into the studio's hallway. Watching the scene, I wondered why they considered manually planning the entire shot easier, but they never told me. I also wanted to know how much leeway they got from George Lucas in terms of plot and story specifics, but again all I got were tiny hints. A better idea would have been one commentary devoted to the Star Wars aspect of Clone Wars, and another to the animation aspect.

That said, it's a pleasure to see that the Star Wars spinoff curse has been broken, and that Clone Wars has joined the ranks of projects like The Animatrix and The Chronicles of Riddick: Dark Fury—animated extensions of high-profile live-action properties that, at their best, add something fresh to an existing mythos. Tartakovsky and company have a lot to be proud of.

DVD Features: Widescreen (1.78:1); English, Spanish and French language tracks; English subtitles; Region 1.

DVD Extras: Bridging the Saga: From Clone Wars to Revenge of the Sith and behind-the-scenes featurettes; two director commentaries; concept art, storyboard and sketches galleries; Star Wars Episode III teaser trailer; video game trailers; Xbox-playable game level.
Page Tools:

E-mail this page   Print this page   Add to del.icio.us   Add to Digg   Add to Fark   Add to FURL   Add to Reddit
> Search
> Site Archives
> Blog Archives
> Upcoming Releases
> RSS Feeds